Relive the Classic New York Pizza Experience

Relive the Classic New York Pizza ExperienceRelive the Classic New York Pizza ExperienceRelive the Classic New York Pizza Experience

Enjoy Our Brick Oven Pizzas,

and Homemade Sauces, Crafted to Deliver the True Taste to Your Buds

Order Now

Relive the Classic New York Pizza Experience

Relive the Classic New York Pizza ExperienceRelive the Classic New York Pizza ExperienceRelive the Classic New York Pizza Experience

Enjoy Our Brick Oven Pizzas,

and Homemade Sauces, Crafted to Deliver the True Taste to Your Buds

Order Now

Why Choose Us

1. Authentic New York Style

Now enjoy New York flavor with our expertly crafted brick oven, Stillwater's Pizza.

2. Delicious Variety

Enjoy our diverse menu, featuring delightful desserts and homemade sauces

Where the Locals Eat

Located in the heart of Stillwater, Oklahoma, Cindy's Pizzas is your go-to destination for authentic New York pizza. Each pizza is crafted with care using traditional techniques and the finest ingredients to bring a slice full of love and flavors to your plate.

Diverse Menu for Every Taste

Our menu features a delightful range of options from New York style Brick oven pizzas baked in house, delicious desserts, homemade sauces and take and baked pizzas. Whether you're a local family or an individual craving a true taste of New York, our offerings promise to deliver a memorable dining experience.

Dive Into Our Menu

Join Our Mailing List

Home
About Us
Menu
Contact Us
Special Offers

Cindy's Pizza

Tue - Sat: 4:00 PM - 9:00 PM | Sun & Mon: Closed

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.